Two Teaspoons is a bakery in Hamburg, NJ. Phone: (973) 823-8432. Average rating is 4.4 stars from 80 reviews. Website: http://twoteaspoonsnj.com/.
Two Teaspoons
Call Now Directions
Review
Exterior view of Two Teaspoons bakery with a welcoming entrance.
4.4 80 reviews

Artful cakes, baked for your biggest moments

Custom cakes and seasonal bakery favorites from Hamburg's cake studio at 2 Main St.

About Us

A cozy bakery interior with a wooden counter and baked goods. — Two Teaspoons
A cozy bakery interior with a wooden counter and baked goods.

At Two Teaspoons, the focus is on cakes that feel personal, look polished, and taste like they were made for the moment you are celebrating. This Hamburg bakery and cake studio works with quality ingredients like butter, chocolate, and seasonal produce, then turns them into custom designs that reflect the occasion, the guest of honor, and the style you want to share.

From custom wedding cakes to celebration pieces made for birthdays, showers, and milestones, the experience is centered on thoughtful detail. The team also offers signature pre-designed cakes for customers who want a beautiful option ready to go, along with cookies, pies, and pastries for holidays and pop-up bakery days. That mix gives locals a place to return to for both planned celebrations and seasonal treats.

The result is a bakery with a creative point of view, one that treats each cake like a centerpiece instead of a routine order. At 2 Main St in Hamburg, Two Teaspoons brings together artistry, flavor, and a clear sense of occasion, making it a natural choice when the dessert needs to feel special before the first slice is served.

What We Offer

If you need a cake that feels designed around your event, Two Teaspoons specializes in custom work that puts your vision first. Their custom wedding cakes and custom celebration cakes are made for moments that deserve more than something ordinary, with attention given to both appearance and flavor.

For gatherings that call for something ready-made, the bakery also offers signature pre-designed cakes that keep the same sense of craft and presentation. These options give customers a polished choice without losing the bakery's distinctive style, making it easier to find something that fits the celebration.

Beyond cakes, the shop rounds out its seasonal offerings with cookies, pies, and pastries for holidays and pop-up bakery days. That means there is always a reason to check back, whether you are planning ahead for a big event or looking for something fresh, festive, and made with care.

Gallery

Take a look at our space and what we have to offer

What Our Customers Say

Don't just take our word for it - hear from our satisfied customers

Click to Rate & Review This Business ✍️
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
5 years ago
"We all know cakes should be delicious and nice to look at, but what Brittany and Maria do is create edible works of art. They took my ideas for a custom cake for my husband’s birthday and delivered a masterpiece that had everyone doing double-takes! They take time to work with you and solidify your ideas on the front end, then take extra care to deliver a product that exceeds expectations (even when those expectations are already sky-high). I highly recommended their cakes for any occasion!"
— Amy Roth
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 years ago
"I just picked up a cake tasting box for my wedding and I think the hardest thing on my list of planning has now become which incredible cake flavor to choose. I am not a big cake person, but I have instantly become one after trying their samples! Bonus: Maria and Brittany are even sweeter than their desserts. Email communication has been stellar and it brightened our day meeting them, they're so personable. My fiancé and I are so excited to be working with them for our wedding this Fall. If you're a Crystal Springs Bride working with Two Teaspoons - you're in good hands! Edit: Post-wedding and I still can't say enough good things about the cake! Sharing some photos of their work :)"
— Meagan Muller
⭐⭐⭐
8 years ago
"Ordered my daughter's bday cake from them. Turned out beautiful but extremely dry and over cooked. Bottom was dark dark brown and the butter cream wasn't very good, very greasy. Not what I expected for $60. Pretty place and good coffee. I'll be back but I won't be ordering cakes."
— christa scott
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
2 years ago
"We had such a wonderful experience working with Two Teaspoons for our wedding cake. We got a cake that served 130 people, the flavors were: chocolate/chocolate and matcha/strawberry and everyone loved it! They matched the vibe of the wedding exactly and we supplied them with a figurine of our pup that they were able to include! We highly recommend them any event!"
— Victoria Gehring
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
3 years ago
"Two Teaspoons made our gender reveal cake and did not disappoint! Not only was it absolutely beautiful, but it was delicious! They listened to every detail I requested. I highly recommend them and will definitely go back to them in the future!"
— Jenna Autorino

Frequently Asked Questions

What does Two Teaspoons specialize in?

Two Teaspoons is a bakery and cake studio focused on custom wedding cakes, custom celebration cakes, and signature pre-designed cakes.

Does Two Teaspoons offer anything besides cakes?

Yes. The bakery also offers cookies, pies, and pastries for holidays and pop-up bakery days.

What kind of ingredients does the bakery emphasize?

Their website highlights quality ingredients such as butter, chocolate, and seasonal produce.

Is Two Teaspoons a good fit for weddings?

Yes. Custom wedding cakes are one of the core services offered by the bakery and cake studio.

Where is Two Teaspoons located?

Two Teaspoons is located at 2 Main St, Hamburg, NJ 07419, USA.

Can I find seasonal items there?

Yes. Seasonal offerings are part of the shop's bakery lineup, especially during holidays and pop-up bakery days.

74° Clear Hamburg
Mon 75° 58°
Tue 74° 58°
Wed 81° 57°
Thu 80° 63°
Fri 79° 62°
Sat 82° 56°
Sun 82° 63°

Get In Touch

Ready to get started? Contact us today!

Save to Contacts

More places nearby

Other spots near here, whatever their type. Tap one to open its page.

Bakery ★ 4.8 (394)
Clove Brook Market | Bakery, Deli, & Catering
5.7 mi800 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461
$$
Bakery ★ 5.0 (15)
Canacopia Edible Treats
2.1 mi409 NJ-23, Franklin, NJ 07416
Bakery ★ 4.8 (698)
Holland American Bakery
2.6 mi246 NJ-23, Sussex, NJ 07461
$$
Fine Dining Restaurant ★ 4.4 (98)
Restaurant Latour
1.4 mi1 Wild Turkey Way, Hamburg
Spa ★ 4.5 (206)
Reflections Spa
1.5 mi3 Wild Turkey Way, Hamburg
Coffee Shop ★ 4.0 (153)
Dunkin'
1.3 mi3672 NJ-94, Hamburg
Sandwich Shop ★ 3.9 (86)
Subway
1.2 mi3672 NJ-94 #3, Hamburg

Contact Two Teaspoons

Send a note and Two Teaspoons will get back to you. No account needed.

Add an email or a phone so they can reply.

Best time to reach you

Report an issue

See something off? Tell us. We’ll fix it and improve the listing for everyone. No account required.